Law Society Excellence Awards Winner!

Suing the NHS: How a Medical Negligence Claim Works

Nayyars Solicitors · Medical Negligence Guide

Suing the NHS: How a Medical Negligence Claim Works

Most people feel deeply grateful to the NHS, which is exactly why the idea of making a claim against it can feel so uncomfortable. You might worry that it is taking money away from patients, that it will affect your future care, or that the process will be long and adversarial. Those feelings are completely understandable.

But when NHS care falls below an acceptable standard and causes avoidable harm, the law gives you the right to compensation, and the system is set up to handle these claims. Suing the NHS for medical negligence is a structured process with clear steps, and claims are dealt with by a specialist body rather than the doctors and nurses who treated you.

This guide explains who you actually claim against, what you need to prove, each stage of the process, how long it takes, and how it is funded. Our medical negligence solicitors bring claims against NHS trusts and GP practices across England and Wales.

Key takeaways
  • In England, claims against NHS trusts and GP practices are handled by NHS Resolution, not by the individual clinicians.
  • You must prove that your care fell below an acceptable standard and that this caused you avoidable harm.
  • Claims follow a set pre-action process, and most settle without going to trial.
  • You usually have three years to start a claim, with special rules for children and people who lack capacity.
  • Making a claim will not affect your right to NHS treatment in the future.

Who do you claim against?

When you sue the NHS, you do not usually bring a claim against an individual doctor, nurse or midwife. In England, claims about hospital care are made against the NHS trust responsible, and they are handled by NHS Resolution, the body that manages negligence claims on behalf of the NHS. Since April 2019, claims about NHS GP services in England have also been covered by a state indemnity scheme run by NHS Resolution.

In Wales, claims are handled through NHS Wales's own arrangements, and there is a separate redress process for some lower-value cases. High street NHS dentists are different again: they hold their own indemnity, so claims are usually brought against the dentist personally.

Knowing who the right defendant is matters, because claims must be directed correctly and in time. Our hospital negligence solicitors will identify the correct organisation at the outset.

What you need to prove

Every medical negligence claim rests on two questions. The first is breach of duty: did the care fall below the standard of a reasonably competent professional in that field? The courts ask whether a responsible body of medical opinion would have supported what was done, while also requiring that the opinion stands up to logical scrutiny.

The second is causation: did that failure cause your injury, or make it worse, compared with what would have happened with proper care? This is often the hardest part. In a delayed diagnosis case, for example, experts must consider what the outcome would have been if the condition had been picked up at the right time.

A poor outcome is not, on its own, proof of negligence. Many treatments carry risks even when done perfectly. A claim succeeds when the harm was avoidable and caused by substandard care.

Consent can also be an issue. Clinicians must explain the material risks of a treatment and the reasonable alternatives. If you were not warned of a significant risk that then happened, and you would have chosen differently, that may support a claim.

Should you complain first?

You do not have to make a complaint before starting a claim, but many people do. The NHS complaints procedure can give you an explanation, an apology and reassurance that lessons will be learned. NHS organisations also have a legal duty of candour, which means they must be open with you when something has gone wrong.

A complaint will not lead to compensation, though, and it does not pause the time limit for a claim. Any response you receive can be useful evidence, so it is worth sharing with your solicitor.

The claims process step by step

NHS claims follow the court's Pre-Action Protocol for the Resolution of Clinical Disputes, which is designed to encourage early settlement. The main stages are:

  1. Initial advice. A free discussion with a solicitor about what happened and whether a claim may be possible.
  2. Medical records. Your solicitor requests your records from the hospital, GP and any other providers.
  3. Expert evidence. Independent medical experts review the records and report on breach of duty and causation.
  4. Letter of Claim. A detailed letter is sent to the NHS body setting out the allegations and the harm caused.
  5. Letter of Response. The NHS body normally has four months to investigate and reply, either admitting or denying liability.
  6. Valuing the claim. Further expert evidence is gathered on your injuries, future needs and financial losses.
  7. Settlement or court. Your solicitor negotiates a settlement, or issues court proceedings if agreement cannot be reached.

Even after proceedings are issued, the vast majority of cases settle before a trial, often after a settlement meeting or mediation. If liability is admitted early, it may be possible to ask for interim payments to help with costs such as care or adaptations while the full value is worked out.

What compensation can cover

Compensation has two parts. General damages reflect your pain, suffering and the impact on your quality of life, valued using the Judicial College Guidelines and previous court decisions. Special damages cover your financial losses, both past and future.

Financial losses can include lost earnings and pension, the cost of care (including care given by family members), private treatment and therapy, equipment, adaptations to your home and travel expenses. In the most serious cases, such as severe birth injuries, future losses may be paid as annual payments for life, known as periodical payments, alongside a lump sum.

Where negligence has led to a death, the family may be able to claim for funeral costs, loss of financial support and a statutory bereavement award. Our fatal claims team supports families through this, including at inquests.

How long does it take?

There is no fixed timescale. A straightforward claim where liability is admitted early may settle in around 12 to 18 months. Complex cases, particularly those involving serious injuries, children or disputed causation, can take several years, because the full extent of the injury and future needs must be understood before the claim can be valued.

Time limits also apply. You generally have three years to start court proceedings, running from the date of the negligence or the date you first knew you had been harmed. For children, the three years start at 18, and for people who lack mental capacity the time limit may not run at all. It is always best to seek advice early.

How claims are funded

Most claims against the NHS are funded on a no win, no fee basis through a conditional fee agreement. If the claim is unsuccessful, you do not pay your solicitor's fees. If it succeeds, most of your legal costs are paid by the NHS body, and a success fee is deducted from your compensation, capped by law at 25% of your damages for pain and suffering and past losses.

Insurance is usually taken out to cover expert fees and other costs if the claim fails. Legal aid is no longer available for most medical negligence claims, but it remains available for some cases involving babies who suffer serious brain injuries during pregnancy, birth or shortly after.

Common worries about suing the NHS

Many people worry that making a claim will affect their future treatment. It will not. You have the same right to NHS care whether or not you bring a claim, and you can ask to be treated by a different clinician if that would make you more comfortable.

Others feel guilty about taking money from the NHS. Compensation exists to put you, as far as money can, back in the position you would have been in without the negligence, often to pay for care and support that you would otherwise go without. Claims also help the NHS learn from mistakes, which protects future patients.

Frequently asked questions

Can you sue the NHS for medical negligence?
Yes. If NHS care fell below an acceptable standard and caused you avoidable harm, you can claim compensation. In England, claims against NHS trusts and GP practices are handled by NHS Resolution.
How long does it take to sue the NHS?
Simpler claims where liability is admitted can settle in around 12 to 18 months. Complex claims, especially those involving serious or long-term injuries, can take several years to resolve.
Will suing the NHS affect my future treatment?
No. Making a claim does not affect your right to NHS treatment. You can also ask to be seen by a different clinician if you would prefer.
Do I have to go to court to sue the NHS?
Usually not. Most medical negligence claims against the NHS settle through negotiation, and very few reach a trial. Court proceedings may be issued to protect the time limit or move the claim forward, but settlement is still the most common outcome.
Who pays compensation when you sue the NHS?
For claims against NHS trusts and GP practices in England, compensation is paid through schemes managed by NHS Resolution, not by the individual doctor or nurse who treated you.

Your Next Steps with Nayyars Solicitors

Taking action against the NHS is a big decision. We will listen, explain your options honestly and handle the claim so you can focus on your recovery.

Call 0333 123 1331

Conclusion

Suing the NHS can feel daunting, but the process is well established. Claims are handled by NHS Resolution rather than the clinicians who treated you, they follow a clear pre-action process, and most settle without a trial. To succeed, you need to show that your care fell below an acceptable standard and that this caused you avoidable harm.

Time limits apply and expert evidence is essential, so early advice makes a real difference. With the right support, you can get answers, compensation for what you have been through and the resources you need for the future.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Every case depends on its own facts, so please contact Nayyars Solicitors for advice specific to your situation.

Medical Negligence Lawyers in England & Wales: Find Specialists

Medical Negligence Lawyers in England & Wales: Find Specialists

If you believe you have been harmed by substandard medical care, it is natural to search for medical negligence solicitors in England and Wales, but not every personal injury firm is truly experienced in this area. Medical negligence, also called clinical negligence, claims are specialist and evidence-heavy, and usually need a solicitor who can guide you through medical records, independent medical experts, and complex questions of causation.

In England and Wales, the best medical negligence lawyers are typically those who regularly handle clinical negligence rather than just general injury claims, can explain breach of duty and causation clearly, have real experience obtaining and analysing medical records, work with appropriate independent medical experts, and offer clear funding options, often including No Win No Fee for suitable cases. Nayyar Solicitors can assess potential medical negligence claims and advise whether you have grounds to pursue compensation, and whether a No Win No Fee agreement may be available depending on the facts and prospects.

Key takeaways
  • The best medical negligence lawyers regularly handle clinical negligence specifically, not just general personal injury claims.
  • A valid claim needs both a breach of duty and proof that the breach caused avoidable harm, not simply a poor outcome.
  • Common claim types include misdiagnosis, surgical errors, medication errors, and birth injury.
  • No Win No Fee can be available, but firms usually carry out a detailed assessment first, given the cost of expert evidence.
  • You generally have three years to claim, though the clock can start later depending on when you reasonably discovered the harm, and different rules apply for children.

What counts as a medical negligence claim?

A medical negligence claim may arise when a healthcare professional or provider, whether NHS or private, delivers care below an acceptable standard and that failure causes harm. Examples can include misdiagnosis or delayed diagnosis, surgical errors, medication errors, a failure to refer or investigate symptoms properly, birth injury or maternity negligence, poor aftercare or discharge planning following hospital treatment, and, depending on the facts, dental negligence. Not every poor outcome is negligence: the key question is always whether the care fell below a reasonable standard and caused avoidable harm.

How to choose a specialist medical negligence solicitor

When comparing firms, rather than instructing any general personal injury lawyer, look for:

  • A dedicated clinical negligence team, or a clear, genuine focus on medical negligence work.
  • A willingness to review your case properly, rather than making instant promises about the outcome.
  • A clear plan for gathering medical records and independent expert evidence.
  • Transparent funding terms, covering the success fee, insurance, and what happens if you lose.
  • Strong communication, since these claims can take time and you need regular updates throughout.
A good medical negligence solicitor will also be honest with you if the evidence does not support a claim, rather than pursuing one regardless.

Can medical negligence claims be No Win No Fee?

Often, yes, but it depends on the strength and complexity of the case. Because medical negligence claims can be more expensive to run, given the cost of expert reports and obtaining medical records, a solicitor will usually carry out a detailed initial assessment before offering a No Win No Fee agreement. Where one is offered, the success fee is legally capped in the same way as other personal injury claims, currently at 25% of your general damages and past financial losses, not future losses.

Time limits for medical negligence claims

Medical negligence claims are generally subject to the same three-year time limit as other personal injury claims under the Limitation Act 1980, running either from the date of the negligent treatment or from your "date of knowledge" if later, meaning when you first knew, or reasonably should have known, that you had suffered significant harm linked to your care. Different rules apply for children: the three-year clock does not start until they turn 18, giving them until their 21st birthday to bring a claim. Claims against the NHS are typically handled by NHS Resolution, the body responsible for managing negligence claims on behalf of NHS organisations in England.

Why choose Nayyar Solicitors for medical negligence claims?

If you are looking for England and Wales medical negligence lawyers who can handle your case with care and clarity, Nayyar Solicitors can assess whether the facts suggest negligence and avoidable harm, explain the likely evidence needed, including records, timelines, and expert input, advise on limitation and time limits, and discuss funding options, including whether No Win No Fee may be available.

Frequently asked questions

Is every poor medical outcome medical negligence?

No. Medicine involves risk, and not every disappointing or unexpected outcome means something went wrong legally. A claim depends on showing the care fell below a reasonable standard and that this specific failure caused avoidable harm.

How long do I have to make a medical negligence claim?

Generally three years from the date of the negligent treatment or from your date of knowledge if later. For children, the three-year clock does not start until they turn 18, giving them until their 21st birthday to claim.

Can I claim against the NHS the same way as a private hospital or clinic?

Yes, though the process differs slightly. NHS claims are typically handled through NHS Resolution, while private hospital and clinic claims are usually made against the provider's own insurer, but the underlying legal test for negligence is the same in both cases.

Will I need to see another doctor as part of my claim?

Usually, yes. Independent medical experts are typically needed to assess whether your care fell below an acceptable standard and whether that failure caused your harm, since this evidence is central to most medical negligence claims.

Your Next Steps with Nayyar Solicitors

If you are asking which personal injury lawyers specialise in medical negligence claims in England and Wales, the best next step is a confidential initial assessment to understand whether you have a viable claim.

Call 0333 123 1331

Conclusion

Medical negligence claims are specialist by nature, and choosing a solicitor with genuine clinical negligence experience, rather than a general personal injury firm, makes a real difference to how your case is handled. Contact Nayyar Solicitors to discuss your medical negligence concerns and find out whether you may be able to claim compensation.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Every case depends on its own facts, so please contact Nayyars Solicitors for advice specific to your situation.

9 Types of Medical Negligence

When you visit a medical professional, the assumption is that they are going to provide you with a high quality of care and treatment. While this is ordinarily the case, there are times when this care falls well below the standard expected, and when it comes to your health, this can have a serious impact.

Of course, medical treatment is not always guaranteed to work. In some cases, the right steps were taken, even if the desired outcome was not achieved. This can make determining medical negligence difficult, as it is not always obvious whether you were the victim of bad care or just bad luck.

If you suspect that you may have suffered medical negligence, one of the best ways to determine whether you have is by looking at the common types of medical negligence.

With that in mind, we are going to share nine types of medical negligence so you can see if any sound like the experience you had.

Before we do, though, it is important to point out that there are many different forms of medical negligence, ranging from botox injury to being prescribed the wrong pills. Due to the wide range of types, you should always speak to a solicitor to identify exactly what type of claim you should make.

Types of Medical Negligence

1. Misdiagnosis

doctor-making-notes-on-clipboard

Misdiagnosis occurs when a medical professional fails to diagnose what condition a patient is suffering from. This may be because they think the patient has a different illness, or because they do not notice their condition at all.

As a result of medical misdiagnosis, a patient may have been prescribed the wrong treatment or none at all, resulting in their condition worsening and potentially even being life-threatening.

Medical misdiagnosis can also take place where there was a delay in identifying the condition.

2. Surgical Negligence

Surgery almost always comes with some inherent risk, but sometimes mistakes are made that should never happen. These ‘never events’ include foreign objects being left in patients or the wrong area of the body being operated on.

In some extreme cases, patients have even had the wrong operation performed on them as a result of clerical mistakes. Alongside mistakes, surgical negligence can also take place where an operation wasn’t necessary in the first place or the patient didn’t fully consent.

3. Anaesthesia

two-surgeons-doing-surgery

Anaesthetic is a common part of medical treatment and something most of us are given at some point in our lives, whether it be in the hospital or at the dentist.

Medical negligence can occur as a result of the improper application or a failure to monitor how it is impacting the patient. The results can range from patients waking up during surgery to brain damage as a result of a lack of oxygen.

4. Prescription and Medication Errors

Thousands of prescriptions are written and dispensed each day, and in rare cases, errors can occur. These mistakes may take the form of the wrong medication or dosage being given to you, medications being prescribed together that should not be, or medications being given to patients despite knowing they are allergic to them.

The consequences of the wrong medication being prescribed or dispensed to you can be serious and can range from digestive problems to death.

5. Long-Term Negligent Treatment

doctor-looking-at-xray

Most medical conditions are not cured overnight. Instead, it is likely that a patient will need long-term treatment or care. Where a medical professional fails to monitor the impact of the treatment properly or does not schedule the correct follow-up appointment, medical negligence can take place.

In these cases, negligent treatment can lead to further illness or injury or the return of the previous condition.

6. Negligent Medical Advice

While most of us rely on a medical professional’s expertise for treatment, patients are still meant to be advised on any risks, side effects or alternatives available. This advice is integral to being able to make an informed decision.

If they fail to advise you in this way and something subsequently goes wrong with your treatment, medical negligence may have taken place.

7. Pregnancy and Birth Injuries

baby-getting-weighed-after-birth

Birth injuries can include any harm the mother or baby suffers either during and after the pregnancy. These injuries can have life-changing ramifications for both mother and child, and examples include cerebral palsy, bowel trauma and maternal diabetes.

Negligence can also take the form of wrongful birth cases, such as where a vasectomy failed or parents were not warned that a child would have been born with a specific injury.

8. Dental Negligence

It is important to note that it is not just your local NHS doctor who can provide negligent care. A number of medical negligence claims come about as a result of low-quality treatment from a dentist.

Dental negligence can occur in many of the ways we have already discussed, from poorly performed surgical procedures to misdiagnosis or inadequate patient care.

9. Negligent Cosmetic Care

Negligent Cosmetic Care

Cosmetic surgery is becoming more and more popular among both men and women. So, it is no surprise that we are seeing a rise in the number of medical negligence cases resulting from cosmetic surgery.

Where cosmetic care is not good enough, individuals can be left with long-lasting physical and emotional damage and may require further care. Medical negligence can arise from a range of cosmetic surgeries including botox and liposuction.

Do You Have a Medical Negligence Claim?

If you suspect that you may have been the victim of medical negligence, it is important that you act quickly. Unless you were under the age of 18 when the suspected negligence happened, in most cases, you only have three years from the date you first realised you had been a victim of medical negligence to make a claim.

While this may seem like a long time, medical negligence claims can take a long time to build, as the evidence you need to provide is extensive. Therefore, you should not waste time in speaking to a solicitor who can review your claim and begin building your case.

So, if negligent medical care has resulted in injury to you, get in touch with the Nayyars team to learn how we can help you.

How to Claim for Medical Negligence in the UK?

If you suspect the medical care you have received was negligent then you may want to make a claim for compensation. However, this can be a daunting proposition, especially when you consider the amount of legal process and jargon you will be exposed to.

In our experience, the success of most medical negligence claims is determined early. Accurately identifying how your care was negligent and gathering evidence to support this position is vital but to do this, you need to understand the claims process as a whole.

We are going to share how to make a claim for medical negligence in the UK here, but before we do, a word of warning. When it comes to pursuing a medical negligence claim, the process is not simple. We are going to highlight each step and what you can do yourself, but the claims process should be handled by an experienced solicitor.

Determining Your Claim

solicitor-and-client-discussing-personal-injury-claim

Perhaps one of the most common reasons for a medical negligence claim failing is because there was not a claim in the first place. That is why, before you invest your time and energy, you need to make sure your case was actually negligent.

Unlike a personal injury claim, where you simply need to show that someone else caused your injury, medical negligence claims have to prove that the care you received contained mistakes that a competent doctor would not have made. This is also known as ‘liability’ or a ‘breach of duty’.

Alongside this, you also need to show causation — that the treatment you received actually caused you harm. This may seem simple but, in fact, it is extremely complex, since you have to show that the harm was not a result of any underlying medical condition.

Proving both liability and causation is no simple task, then, and one of the reasons you should seek the help of an expert.

While you are determining the validity of your claim, you also need to ensure you know exactly who you are claiming against. In many cases, the defendant is not the person who provided you with the negligent care. An obvious example is in the NHS, where a doctor may be at fault, but you would claim against the NHS Trust.

Likewise, you will also need to give some thought to what damages you have incurred as a result of your care. When we talk about damages, we are referring to what your negligent care has cost you. Damages could anything from a loss of earnings to expenses for additional treatment or equipment.

Again, putting a number on what your care has cost you can be difficult, especially if you do not have a prognosis for how your resultant injury or condition will impact you in the future. However, it is important that you are as accurate as possible, as the last thing you want to do is claim for too little.

Using an Official Complaints Procedure

Once you are comfortable that you have been a victim of medical negligence, it is time to start the claims process. However, before we talk about that, let us take a moment to review another option you can pursue yourself.

In almost all cases, if you have received negligent care there is an official procedure for making an official complaint. While you do not have to make a complaint before launching legal action, it can be useful to do so if you are not exactly sure what happened and want more information.

Making a complaint should not be viewed as an alternative for making a legal claim for medical negligence. In fact, in most NHS cases, a complaint can be investigated while you pursue your claim. Only in rare cases could the two conflict, such as if a judge ruled that an investigation into your care by the NHS would interfere with your legal case.

Gathering Evidence

xray-showing-broken-shoulder-bone

For the reasons already mentioned, gathering evidence is a huge part of claim success. It is not enough to simply show that you have been hurt while in the care of a medical professional. To prove negligence, you need to demonstrate that the actions (or lack of) taken would not have been done by a competent professional.

The collection of this evidence needs to be comprehensive, which can make the task time-consuming and complex. For that reason, evidence gathering is best conducted by a solicitor.

As a starting point, your solicitor will apply for your medical records. This will include the necessary treatment information, as well as any evidence of your condition before and after treatment, such as x-rays.

What other evidence is required will depend entirely on the specifics of your case. For example, if your care left you with visible bruises, documenting this with photographs is essential.

Likewise, if the negligence has left you unable to work or having to pay additional costs for ongoing treatment, your solicitor will work with you to identify exactly what damages you can claim for.

Speaking to a Medical Expert

One of the most important elements of the evidence gathering is seeking the advice of a medical expert. First and foremost, this is key to identifying the severity of the damage caused and how long it should be expected to last. Only with this information can you accurately calculate what your claim is worth.

Secondly, a medical expert will be able to give some insight into whether the care you received fell below the expected standards of a professional. Again, this is key to proving negligence took place.

Sending a Letter of Claim

Once you have substantiated your claim with the required evidence, it is time to bring it to the attention of the defendant. This is done by sending a letter of claim, which alleges the negligence. Alongside the allegation, the letter sets out key information, such as the legal basis and the amount of damages you are claiming.

Once the defendant receives the letter, they then have 14 days to reply, and a further four months to provide a detailed response. Their response will come in one of the following ways:

  • A full denial of the claim
  • A denial of part of the claim
  • An offer to settle, either with or without admitting negligence

If the claim is denied then your solicitor may choose to gather further evidence in preparation for the potential that the case may need to be decided in court.

Negotiating a Settlement

solicitors-and-client-agreeing-settlement-with-defendant

While your case going to court is always a possibility, the good news is that it rarely becomes an eventuality. It is almost always more advantageous for both parties to settle the claim out of court, so this is what your solicitor will aim to do.

If your claim is against the NHS, then the chances of successfully agreeing a settlement are high. If you make a claim against the NHS they are usually represented by the NHS Litigation Authority. Of the cases they handle, fewer than 2% reach court. The rest are either settled or dropped.

Issuing Court Proceedings

If your case cannot be settled, then the next step is for your solicitor to issue court proceedings.

Doing so requires submitting paperwork to the court, along with providing copies of evidence, such as expert opinions and information about loss of earnings now and in the future. The defendant will then file their defence to the claim with the court.

The value and complexity of the claim will determine where your case is heard, with lower value claims typically heard in the County Court and higher value claims heard in the High Court.

Court dates will then be set in which your solicitor can put your claim before a judge. The judge will then write to both parties to inform you whether your claim was successful and the amount of compensation you will be awarded.

Finally, issuing proceedings is not a guarantee that your case will go to court. The gears in court move slowly, so during this time there is still the chance that your claim can be settled.

How Long Do You Have to Claim?

analog-clock-on-white-wall

If you think you have suffered medical negligence then it is important to act quickly as you only have three years from the date of realising your care is negligent. For children, they have until their 21st birthday, and if someone dies as a result of medical negligence, their family has three years from the date of the death to pursue a claim.

While three years may seem like a long time, it is not when you consider the volume of information and evidence that needs to be gathered. Therefore, it is important to speak to a solicitor as early as possible so you can start building a strong claim from day one.

So, if you think you may have a claim for medical negligence, get in touch with the team at Nayyars Solicitors to find out how we can help you on a no-win-no-fee basis.

How to Prove Medical Negligence

Medical negligence can leave a lasting impact, both physically and emotionally. If you think you have been the victim of negligent care by a medical professional, a good way to begin healing some of the damage is by making a claim.

However, medical negligence claims are rarely straightforward and many people struggle to prove that they are even a victim in the first place. For that reason, collecting enough evidence for your claim is vital.

When it comes to proving your medical negligence claim, there is no substitute for an experienced solicitor. In this article, we are going to share some of the steps you or your solicitor will need to take in order to prove that medical negligence actually took place.

Determining Whether You are a Victim of Negligence

When it comes to illness or injury there is always the risk that even with the right care, treatment can fail. This poses a challenge for potential victims of negligence, as the first question is always whether the damage was the result of bad care or the underlying medical condition.

So, before you embark on your claim, you need to ensure what happened to you definitely qualifies as negligence. You will need to speak to a solicitor for a definitive answer when it comes to your case, but for now, here is a general definition:

  • You must have been owed a duty of care by a medical professional
  • That duty must have been breached
  • As a result of the breach, you must have suffered a physical and/or mental injury
  • The injury you suffered must have resulted in a loss

How to Prove Medical Negligence

adult-man-suffering-from-back-pain-after-medical-negligence

While it may seem obvious to you that medical negligence took place, it is up to you to be able to prove it in court. With this burden of proof on your shoulders, the effective gathering of evidence becomes paramount.

This evidence can come in all shapes and sizes depending on the specifics of your claim, but below are five common forms of evidence to gather.

1. Collect Medical Records

The first step in proving medical negligence is collecting your medical records, a task ordinarily completed by your solicitor. This will allow you to build a picture of the underlying issue you required treatment for and scrutinise whether the care you provided was reasonable.

Alongside demonstrating why you required care, reviewing your records is important for identifying other relevant medical entries that could impact your case. While this information will not necessarily affect the amount of compensation you receive, it may need to be referred to in the expert’s report – something we will look at in more detail later.

2. Track Your Injuries

Depending on the nature of your injury, you may be able to track its progression with photographs. They say a photo is worth a thousand words and this is certainly the case when it comes to medical negligence, as it can save you trying to describe your injury.

Photos can then be used together with the opinions of an expert to draw a comparison between what the outcome of your treatment should have looked like, and what it actually looked like.

Alongside photographs, you can also track your injuries by keeping notes on how they are impacting you each day. At the very least, these notes will allow you to easily recall how your injury progressed.

3. Document the Impact

woman-making-notes-on-medical-negligence-in-diary

It goes without saying that medical negligence will have serious ramifications on your health, but you should also be sure to document the impact it has on your day to day life.

This could include noting when you first became aware that you may have experienced negligent treatment and keeping your own records of medical appointments, including the treatment provided and any advice you are given.

In order to accurately calculate the damages you will claim for, you should also take care to track any expenses you have incurred as a result of the negligence. This could include travel for appointments, loss of earnings, the cost of private medical treatment or therapy, and the purchase of equipment, such as a wheelchair.

4. Look for Witnesses

The next step in the evidence-gathering process is to look for witnesses who can provide statements relating to the negligence. The closer to the point of negligence the better, so, for example, another medical professional present would be ideal, though this is not always possible.

At the very least, you can provide your own witness statement. You can also gather statements from your family and friends to provide insights into how the negligence has impacted your life.

5. Gather Medical Experts

One of the most fundamental parts of the evidence-gathering process is speaking to a medical expert who can provide a report on your condition and when or if you are likely to fully recover.

This is essential in determining not only whether medical negligence took place, but also what damages you can claim for. Without an expert, it is extremely difficult to prove that the care you received was negligent, simply because it is unlikely you will have the required experience or knowledge.

An expert’s report can be organised by your solicitor and aside from strengthening your case, can, in some circumstances, also provide you with some closure when coming to terms with how the negligence will affect your life.

Difficulties in Proving Medical Negligence

adult-woman-stress-with-medical-negligence-claim

Throughout this article, we have highlighted the need to use a solicitor when putting together your medical negligence claim. The reason for this is that medical negligence claims are notoriously complex and often throw up difficulties that require legal expertise.

Common difficulties people face in medical negligence claims include:

  • Proving harm was caused by negligence and not the underlying condition that was being treated.
  • Passing the ‘Bolam’ test and proving that the medical professional did not act according to accepted and proper practice.
  • Passing the ‘Bolitho’ test and proving that the defence of the medical negligence (eg. the body of doctors and supporting witnesses) cannot withstand logical analysis.
  • Finding an expert that can speak authoritatively on your injury and the care that you were provided.
  • Proving ‘invisible’ injuries. Where negligence has resulted in damage to your mental health, gathering proof of the existence and extent of the injury can be extremely difficult.

How Long Do You Have to Prove Medical Negligence?

If you suspect you have a medical negligence claim then time is of the essence. In most cases, the time limit for bringing a claim for medical negligence is three years. That means three years start from the date of the negligence or from the date that you have knowledge of certain facts that make up your claim, as is set out in the Limitation Act 1980.

In some cases, this time limit is different. For example:

  • Children who have experienced negligence have three years from the start of their 18th birthday.
  • Those who experienced negligence when they were unable to deal with their affairs have three years to make a claim once they regain the ability to do so.
  • The court can allow claims outside the three years if they think there was a good reason for the delay.

What is important to realise is while three years may seem a long time, it can be quite a tight deadline when you consider how much evidence you need to gather before your claim can be made.

Start Your Claim

Proving medical negligence is no simple task. Therefore, it can take a long time to build a strong case, which is why you should speak to a solicitor as soon as possible.

If you suspect you may have a valid medical negligence claim, get in touch with Nayyars’ Solicitors to find out how we can help you.

11 Questions about the Medical Negligence Claims Process

If you suspect you’ve been the victim of medical negligence, you may be owed compensation for your injuries. If this is the case, you’ll need to make a claim, but for anyone unfamiliar with this area of the law, that can be a daunting task.

Over years of helping people pursue their claims, we’ve heard the same questions about the medical negligence claims process time and time again. Below are the answers to some of the most common ones we’ve heard.

1. What is Medical Negligence?

man-in-hospital-gown-using-walker-after-medical-negligence

Medical negligence, also known as clinical negligence, is when a medical practitioner provides care that falls well below the standard expected of someone in their position. This, as a result, then causes damage to your health that would not have occurred otherwise.

Medical practitioners have what is known as a ‘duty of care’ to you as a patient. Medical negligence occurs when this duty is breached by the practitioner.

2. Who Does Medical Negligence Apply To?

Medical negligence doesn’t just apply to your local NHS doctor. Any and all health practitioners can be held liable if they have acted negligently in your care.

As such, medical negligence could apply to dentists, cosmetic surgeons, private clinics, and eye clinics. If you’re unsure whether someone is able to commit medical negligence, contact a solicitor for advice.

3. Who Will My Claim Be Against?

One of the most important steps of a medical negligence claim is to correctly identify who is at fault for the failure to provide you with adequate care.

In many cases, it may not be the individual who directly treated you who is liable. For example, if your care was given at an NHS hospital, you would most likely claim against the NHS Trust that manages the hospital, not the medical professional themselves.

Of course, who to claim against depends on the details of your case, but identifying the right person or organisation early is essential to success.

4. How Do I Start a Claim?

solicitors-reviewing-claim-notes

If you want to make a claim for medical negligence it’s important you seek the support of a professional solicitor as soon as possible. While you may know what happened, demonstrating the exact details and how they constitute negligence under the law can be a complex process and not one to be taken lightly.

Your solicitor will start by identifying the legal basis for your claim and will be able to set your expectations for how long the claim will likely take to complete, along with a rough idea of how much it may be worth.

5. What Proof Will I Need?

Depending on the extent of your negligence, providing evidence may not be simple.

Your Solicitor will need to obtain copies of your medical records from your GP or hospital. If the negligence has left physical marks, such as bruises, it’s important to document these as soon as possible as photos.

Your solicitor may also need to gather witness statements from those who were present at the time of the negligence, or have information pertaining to it. You should also keep a log of anything you’re unable to do as a result of the negligence and any times where you need additional help, such as when doing housework.

Your Solicitor will usually instruct an independent medical examination to determine the extent of your injuries.

6. Do I Need a Medical Expert as a Witness?

As part of the evidence gathering for your claim, your solicitor will seek a report from a medical expert to demonstrate the severity of the damaged caused by the negligence. This will help demonstrate not only the short-term damage you suffered but also how the negligence will impact you in the future, such as limiting your ability to work.

An expert may also be used to comment on any medical practices and process that were used and contributed to the failure in your care.

7. How Long Will My Claim Take?

black-alarm-clock-on-desk

It’s impossible to give an accurate answer as to how long your claim will take without knowing the details of your case, but you should be prepared for it to take months rather than days.

This is for the simple reason that time has to be given to the person or organisation liable to investigate your case and either admit or deny fault.

From there, your solicitor will either have to gather more evidence to further your claim or negotiate your settlement on your behalf. In the event that a settlement cannot be reached and the claim has to go to court, the time it takes can increase drastically.

The length of time your claim takes is one of the topics you should discuss in the initial consultation when selecting a solicitor.

8. Will I Have to Go to Trial?

One of the most daunting elements of a medical negligence claim is the prospect that you may have to go to court. While this is always a possibility, you and your solicitor should always see it as a last resort.

In practice, the majority of medical negligence claims are settled outside of court and your solicitor should take all steps to negotiate a settlement as quickly as possible. Avoiding court proceedings should drastically reduce the time it takes to resolve your claim and keep costs to a minimum.

9. How Long Do I Have to Claim?

If you suspect you have a claim for medical negligence it is important you move quickly, as you are likely to only have three years from the point you become aware of the negligence (usually the point at which it took place) to file your claim with the court.

This may seem like a long time, but it can easily take well over a year to negotiate with the liable party and decide whether you need to take the claim to court, so don’t waste time wondering and speak to a solicitor as soon as possible.

There are circumstances where the court does not impose this time limit, such as if the claimant is under 18 or lacks mental capacity, but for most people, it’s unlikely you’ll get an extension.

10. How Much Will My Claim Cost?

calculator-next-to-costs-spreadsheet

Just as with how long your claim may take, it’s impossible to say how much your claim will cost you without knowing the details of your case.

However, in most medical negligence cases the risk of high costs is negated. This is because many solicitors offer a no-win-no-fee basis, so you won’t pay their costs unless you win compensation.

A solicitor can also help you take out an insurance policy against having to pay the legal costs of the defending party should you lose.

11. What is My Claim Worth?

The only way to find out what your claim is worth is to speak to an experienced medical negligence solicitor.

Get in touch with Nayyars Solicitors to find out if you have a medical negligence claim and what you could be owed.

Medical Negligence – Can I Make a Claim?

If you have been to a doctor or nurse or anyone in the medical profession and are worried that they did not provide you with the right standard of treatment then we can investigate a medical negligence claim for you.

The legal definition of medical negligence (also known as clinical negligence) is very strict. You must prove the following two conditions:

  1. Liability – you will have to prove that the Doctor or Nurse provided you with treatment below the standard that a similar professional would have done.
  2. Causation – that negligence has caused your harm. The harm would not have otherwise occurred if the correct medical treatment had been provided to you.

The case will fail if other doctors state that they would have done the same or that treatment was one of a range of options of treatment available to you. Even though at the end it may have not been the best option, if it was a reasonable option available at the time then the case will not succeed.

The time limit for making these cases is 3 years from the date of knowledge that the treatment was negligent. This could be the exact date of the treatment or you could find out that it was negligent later. For children then have until their 21st birthday to start a claim for medical negligence. If someone dies as a result of medical negligence then their family have 3 years from the date of the death to pursue a claim.

If you suspect there may have been negligence then you should contact solicitors straight away. These cases are run on a no win no fee basis. Once we have taken full details from you we will apply for your medical records. A formal Letter of Claim is then sent to the Hospital Trust or Doctor alleging negligence. The Defendant then has 4 months within which to either admit the negligence or deny it giving reasons. If liability is denied then medical evidence is obtained to determine whether negligence did occur.

If it can be proved that negligence did occur then we would claim compensation for both injury and financial losses caused as a result.

At Nayyars we are experts in dealing with clinical negligence claims and deal with such cases in a confidential and sympathetic manner.

If you would like to speak to us please call 0161 491 8520.

All Locations